Anyone can call themselves a career coach. In the US, a licensed counselor needs a graduate degree, supervised hours and an exam. A coach needs nothing. As Emily Hemendinger wrote in The Conversation, "coaching does not require licensing, credentialing or formal education" (republished by WUNC, 10 September 2024). Some coaches are excellent. Some have no training at all. The checking is your job.
This guide gives you the questions to ask on the free intro call, the red flags, and a way to tell whether you need a coach or a counselor. One disclosure first: I sell a EUR 19 report and one-off strategy sessions, so I compete with coaches for some of the same people. Read me with that in view.
Coach or counselor: which one you need
People use the two words for the same job. The training behind them differs a lot.
- A licensed counselor in the US holds a state license. Titles include Licensed Professional Counselor (LPC), and the rules vary by state. To get one you need a master's degree in counseling or a related field, supervised hours and an exam (American Counseling Association). The National Career Development Association adds a career-specific credential, the Certified Career Counselor, which needs a master's degree or higher in a counseling field (NCDA).
- A coach works on action: choosing a direction, planning the move, keeping you to it. Training ranges from none to hundreds of hours.
- In the Netherlands, look for a Register Loopbaanprofessional. Noloc, the Dutch association for career professionals, certifies people with education at hbo level and 600 hours of relevant experience in the three years before they apply. DNV does the assessment, the certificate lasts four years, and you can search the register without an account (Noloc).
If your career question comes with weeks of poor sleep, dread or low mood, start with a doctor or a licensed counselor. A coach is the wrong first stop for that, and a good one will tell you so. If it is mostly a question about direction and next steps, a coach can help. The full comparison, including insurance and the UK, is in career coach vs career counselor.
What a coaching credential tells you
The best-known coaching credentials come from the International Coaching Federation (ICF). There are three levels (ICF credential paths):
- ACC: 60 or more hours of coach training and 100 or more hours of coaching with at least 8 clients.
- PCC: 125 or more hours of training and 500 or more hours of coaching with at least 25 clients.
- MCC: 200 or more hours of training and 2,500 or more hours of coaching with at least 35 clients.
You can check a claim in about a minute with ICF's Verify a Coach tool. Do it. A coach who lists a credential the tool cannot find has told you something important.
A credential proves training and practice hours. It does not prove the coach knows your field or has helped anyone in your situation. A PCC who coaches sales managers may be the wrong person for a nurse who wants out of healthcare. Treat it as a floor. The intro call does the rest.
Eight questions to ask on the intro call
Most coaches offer a free first call. Use it as an interview, with you asking the questions.
- "Who do you usually work with?" You want a clear answer that sounds like you. "Everyone" is the wrong answer.
- "What does a typical engagement look like, from first session to last?" Listen for a structure. How many sessions, how far apart, and what happens in each.
- "What is the total cost, and what happens if I stop after two sessions?" Get the full number, including any assessments. Typical career coaching runs $75 to $250 an hour, and packages run $1,000 to $2,500 (what a career coach costs). Ask about refunds before you pay.
- "What will I do between sessions?" Coaching works when you do the work in between. A coach with no answer is selling conversation.
- "How will we know, by week six, whether this is working?" A good coach names a checkpoint. A vague answer here becomes a vague engagement later.
- "When do you send someone to a different professional?" The ICF Code of Ethics asks coaches to watch whether coaching still helps. If it stops helping, they explore "a different coach, professional, or resource" with the client (ICF Code of Ethics, 4.3). A coach who says it never happens has not thought about it.
- "What would make you tell me I don't need a coach?" The honest ones have an answer. Some people need a single session, a book or a conversation with a friend in the field.
- "Can we spend ten minutes on my real question now?" Watch what they do with it. Good coaches ask questions that make you stop and think. Weak ones fill the time with their own story.
Talk to two or three coaches before you choose. After each call, write down one thing you now see differently. If the list is empty, keep looking.
Red flags to walk away from
- A guaranteed job, salary or result. Nobody controls a hiring decision except the employer. The US Federal Trade Commission's advice on job scams says: "Don't pay for the promise of a job" (FTC, Job Scams). That warning is about placement firms, and the logic carries over. Pay for help, never for a promise.
- Vague qualifications. The ICF Code asks coaches to "accurately identify my coaching qualifications" (clause 5.1). If you ask about training and get a story instead of a name and a number, note it.
- Pressure to commit today. A price that expires at the end of the call, or a six-month package as the only option. You are buying months of someone's time, so take a night to think.
- The answer arrives before the questions. A coach who tells you in the first call which career to pick has not heard enough to know. Coaches help you decide. They do not decide for you.
- No interest in the rest of your life. Money, family and health shape every career change. A coach who only wants to talk about your CV will miss the reason you are stuck.
- Brushing off how you feel. If you mention months of dread and the coach steers straight back to the plan, they are working outside their limits.
What I would do before hiring anyone
Do the cheap steps first. Write answers to the six questions, and try one or two of the free options in alternatives to a career coach. You will arrive at the intro call knowing what you want help with, and you will need fewer sessions.
If you are worn out, read burnout or the wrong career before you book anything. Then pick the coach whose questions made you think hardest, not the one with the nicest website.
Quick answers
Do career coaches need a license?
No. In the US anyone can call themselves a career coach, with no license, credential or formal education needed. A licensed counselor is different: titles such as Licensed Professional Counselor need a master's degree, supervised hours and an exam, with rules that vary by state. Many coaches hold a voluntary ICF credential, which you can check with ICF's Verify a Coach tool.
What questions should I ask a career coach before hiring?
Ask who they usually work with and what a full engagement looks like. Ask the total cost and what happens if you stop early. Find out what you will do between sessions, how you will both know by week six that it is working, and when they send someone to a different professional. Then ask to spend ten minutes on your real question and watch how they handle it.
What are the red flags when hiring a career coach?
A guaranteed job or salary, vague answers about training, and pressure to sign up on the first call. Also a coach who tells you which career to pick before hearing you out, or who steers past signs that you are struggling. Talk to two or three coaches and pick the one whose questions made you think hardest.